Researchers from the University of Pittsburgh recruited participants at Black Pride events in six American cities from 2014 to 2017. Most participants were men who have sex with men, but this analysis focuses on a sub-sample of 422 transgender women. They were all assigned male sex at birth and currently identified as female or transgender. All were black and had sex with men.
Their average age was 30 years. Social challenges such as problems accessing healthcare, incarceration, homelessness, sex work and limited education were frequently reported.
Researchers wished to characterise the HIV care continuum, as this has not previously been described in black transgender women.
HIV testing conducted as part of the study showed that 45% of participants were living with HIV (190 women). Just 41% of them (78) were aware of this.
Engagement with the next few stages of the care continuum was much better – 75 of the 78 diagnosed women were linked to care, 72 were retained in care and 65 were receiving HIV treatment. However, only 45 transgender women reported an undetectable viral load.
In percentages from stage to stage, the care continuum is therefore 41% diagnosed, 96% linked to care, 96% retained in care, 90% on treatment, 69% virally suppressed.
Only 24% of this group was diagnosed, in care and virally suppressed compared with the 90-90-90 target of 72.9%.
It appears that there are many barriers to transgender women learning their HIV status. The authors suggest that apprehension about receiving a diagnosis that will require them to use healthcare services where they may be stigmatised may be a factor. But once women take action to learn their status, most are ready to access HIV treatment and care.
The researchers examined factors that were associated with having undiagnosed HIV. In comparison with HIV-negative participants, undiagnosed participants were more likely to have been incarcerated (42% versus 32%) and to report being unable to access health care (54% vs 40%). After adjustment for other factors that could influence these results, these differences remained statistically significant.
Similarly, analysis of factors associated with not being virally suppressed showed that poor treatment outcomes were more common in those recently incarcerated (59% vs 29%), homeless (71% vs 39%), using multiple illicit drugs (50% vs 18%), reporting physical assault (73% vs 47%) and receiving hormone treatment (86% vs 47%). These differences were statistically significant.
The finding that women receiving hormones were less likely to be virally suppressed may reflect women prioritising hormonal therapies for gender reassignment over HIV treatment, especially in the face of economic challenges.
More broadly, the researchers say that their findings underscore “the need for trauma-informed care”. Interventions should address the multiple challenges that black transgender women face and address the fundamental causes of poor health.
Author: Roger Pebody